We knew when we moved in that we were going to change out the flooring. The previous owner was a smoker and we are not. I could smell it the second I walked in and knew that removing the carpet would be a big help in getting rid of those odors. Besides, I am not that fond of berber carpet.
The ceramic tile was blue and I would rather not have a strong color on such a large surface. I like blue, but not on the floor.
I began daydreaming about flooring before we even moved. My brother, Patrick,who owns a construction/remodeling company in Iowa, is planning to come down and help us do a few things to begin making our house, truly ours. He is an amazing carpenter/handyman/”anything you need done to your house” guy. Originally, his plan was to help us with the flooring, but after the last post, you can see our plans have changed into a rather large project. It would be hard to do flooring before we do the major renovations in the kitchen, since we are knocking out and moving walls.
I will most likely paint the light oak woodwork and cabinets white, so I want something that will go nicely with that. The layout of the house is an open floor plan where the living room, kitchen and dining room flow into each other. My thought is to do a hard surface through out and then get an area rug for the living room.
It is overwhelming the number of choices out there. I love hard wood and it can be timeless, but I was very disappointed on how easily the wood floor in our previous house scratched.
Tile is very durable, but unless we pick a high end natural tile, it will most likely be “dated” a few years from now. It is also much more labor intensive to lay than wood.
There are a lot of laminate wood products available, but most seem to look fake to me. I’m trying not to be picky but if we are going to the expense to replace the flooring I want to make sure I like it.
After Tim and I hashed through the pros and cons of each option, we decided to try to find a tile that hopefully would be reasonably priced but look like natural stone or even tile that looks like wood planks.
I called Patrick and told him our thoughts. He asked if we had ever considered bamboo. Sounded pretty strange to me, but we agreed to go to Lumber Liquidators and look.
When my daughter, Lauren, was in town, Tim and I dragged her with us to look at bamboo because I value her opinion. When we got to Lumber Liquidators, the salesman was very helpful and informative. We looked at bamboo, and it is a nice option, I just couldn't find a color I liked. We started talking to him about the hard wood floor in our old house and this opened up a whole wealth of information.
It seems that there are many types of walnut-which was the flooring in our old home. We probably got American Walnut which is much softer than oak. Wood is given a “Janka” rating, which compares each variety of wood to one another. Most all wood is compared to Red Oak. American walnut has a lower Janka rating than Red Oak, yet Brazilian Walnut is almost 4 times harder than Red Oak. This information relieved my concerns about using wood again.
So we looked at what was available and came up with these samples to take home.
We had pretty much decided on the front sample. It is solid oak, but it is hand scraped and has a lot of color variation within each piece. My thought is that even if we do scratch it, we could take a brown or black marker and touch it up and no one would know.
I had pretty much settled for that until I happened to be looking for extra cabinets to fill in where we are taking the pantry out. The sales person showed me an engineered Elm that I totally fell in love with and it was about 1/3 less expensive than the oak. I was a little hesitant to use engineered wood because only the top layer is the desired wood and the rest is multiple layers of plywood, but this product has a 30 year finish guarantee.
The pro’s of engineered wood are:
- It is generally a little less expensive than solid wood
- The layers of plywood fight against each other, keeping the wood more stable so there is usually less expansion and contraction of the joints.
Cons are:
- Can generally only be refinished once.
The pros of solid wood are:
- Can be refinished multiple times and the surface will remain the same wood clear through.
Cons are:
- Generally more expensive
- Seams between each piece of wood are more likely to expand and contract.
I failed to get a picture of the flooring but it is similar in color to the Oak from above. The hand scraped ridges are more irregular giving it a more authentic feel of wood that has been in place for a long time. There just seemed to be a lot more pattern and grain in the Elm sample. I am really excited to see it on the floor.